I ordered some of these to replace my mouthpiece that got ripped on a recent dive trip. Not sure what to think, I ordered 4, two were identical with the Italy molded on the mouthpiece. I know ScubaPro is a South African company, but ok, maybe they outsourced their mouthpiece to Italy. I actually ordered one from Amazon, and got the same mouthpiece, so fine, it's not like the Scubapro Mouthpiece that came with my regulator, and it doesn't have ScubaPro molded into the rubber/vinyl, no big deal, it goes in my mouth and I'm not looking to win any fashion awards. I has a slightly different contour, but I can live with that, a different type of "feel" or texture, again, I can live with it.
The other two were different from one another; as well as, the two that matched the Scubapro Mouthpiece shipped by Amazon. They came in different packaging, with Divecatalog.com stickers. Maybe they (Divecatalog.com) were out of the "ScubaPro" mouthpieces and the warehouse package two other mouthpieces so the order could be fulfilled, ok, I get it. Divecatalog.com was just trying to do me a favor, and make everyone's life easier.
Of the four, two appear to have been opened and returned, as they were taped close with a torn plastic wrapper. None of the 4 plastic wrappers were the same.
I think I will just return them, I purchase two of the colored ScubaPro replacement mouthpieces that come packaged with the hose guard, they are the same as the original mouthpiece, just not black. I'll pay for the combined kit, yes it's more expensive, but other than the color, it matches what my regulator came with, and they have served me well for 80 dives!